August 10, 2026 | Dear Marci

What factors should I consider when choosing a Medicare Advantage Plan?

Dear Marci,

I’m in my Initial Enrollment Period and thinking about maybe enrolling in a Medicare Advantage Plan. What factors should I consider when choosing between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage, and in selecting an MA Plan? 

– Dean (Oxford, MS)

Dear Dean, 

Great question! When you are choosing between Medicare Advantage Plans, below are some questions to keep in mind. 

Providers, hospitals, and other facilities 

  • Will I be able to use my doctors? Are they in the plan’s network? 
  • Do doctors and providers I want to see in the future take new patients who have this plan? 
  • If my providers are not in-network, will the plan still cover my visits? What is the difference in my costs? 
  • Which specialists, hospitals, home health agencies, and skilled nursing facilities are in the plan’s network? 
  • How important is it to me to be able to choose any provider I wish to see?  

Access to health care 

  • What is the service area for the plan? 
  • Do I have any coverage for care received outside the service area (in addition to urgent or emergency care)? 
  • Who can I choose as my primary care provider (PCP)? 
  • Does my doctor need to get approval from the plan to admit me to a hospital? 
  • Do I need a referral from my PCP or approval from the plan to see a specialist? 

Costs 

  • What costs should I expect for my coverage (premiums, deductibles, copayments)? 
  • What is the annual maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP) cost? 
    • Note: PPOs have different out-of-pocket limits for in-network and out-of-network care. If you’re considering a PPO, find out what the different out-of-pocket limits are for in-network and out-of-network care. 
  • How much will I have to pay out of pocket before coverage starts (what is the deductible)? 
  • How much is my copayment for services I regularly receive, such as PCP or specialist care? 
  • How much will I pay if I visit an out-of-network provider or facility? 
  • Are there higher copays for certain types of care, such as hospital stays or home health care? 

Benefits 

  • Does the plan cover any services that Original Medicare does not (supplemental services)? 
  • Are there any rules or restrictions I should be aware of when accessing these benefits?  
  • What are costs and limits to this coverage? How does it compare to stand alone insurance or paying out of pocket for that care?  
  • Are any of these services covered by other programs I might be eligible for (like Medicaid)?  

Prescription drugs 

  • Are my prescriptions on the plan’s formulary?  
  • Does the plan impose any coverage restrictions?  
  • What costs should I expect to pay for my drug coverage (premiums, deductibles, copayments)?  
  • How much will I have to pay for brand-name drugs?  
  • How much for generic drugs?  
  • What will I pay for my drugs during the coverage gap? 
  • Will I be able to use my pharmacy? Can I get my drugs through mail order? 
  • Will the plan cover my prescriptions when I travel? 

Coordination of benefits 

  • How does the plan work with any other coverage I have (Medicaid, retiree, job-based)? 
  • If I join, would I lose my job-based insurance or retiree coverage? 

Hope this helps! 

-Marci 

Glossary Terms

Was this Information Helpful?

Thank you for your response. Please help us improve MI by filling out this short survey.

SKIP SURVEY RESUME SURVEY